title
B&H Photo - Video - Pro Audio
Search and Shop at the B&H Store

Articles and Reviews

Photography

Edwin's World

Readers' Gallery

Site Map

NikonLinks

Wedding Photography


 

 

 

Home >> Photography >> Digital

Copperhill Sensor Sweep Cleaning Brush
July 18, 2005

Earlier this year, I purchased the Sensor Brush from a Canadian outfit based in Alberta, to clean my D100 D-SLR’s sensor. I purchased it after reading the glowing review of it at noted digital guru Rob Galbraith’s website. It was an expensive purchase for what appears to be a very simple brush, at CAN $108 for the Sensor Brush and another brush meant for field use. Add to that a minimum of CAN $8 for S&H, or if you’re very indulgent, CAN $45 for FedEx delivery, and we’re talking about a pretty big chunk of coin for a cleaning brush that looks little different than cosmetics brushes found in a drug store, but at over 20X the price.

The Sensor Brush is a dry-clean tool, meaning no wet solutions need to be used that can result in streaks on the sensor (actually, it’s the protective filter, or glass above the sensor that you’re actually cleaning in most D-SLRs). It works by charging the nylon filaments of the brush by blowing it with compressed air, the readily available kind that you buy for cleaning computer parts. The charged nylon filaments will then attract most if not all of the dust on the sensor and it does a good enough job that you may never have to worry about doing a wet cleaning again.

The Sensor Brush works as advertised, but still, it costs $108 (plus S&H), which is no small change for something that comes nowhere near looking like it's worth a C-note. It’s also interesting to see a FAQ at the VisibleDust website that tries to trump the Sensor Brush over other types of brushes as being superior and attempting to justify the very high price because camera companies charge so much for their own cleaning services, e.g. Nikon Canada charges CAN $80 plus tax for a sensor cleaning.

An article about how the Sensor Brush works and what its true origins might be was posted on the Internet last year. One would surmise that eventually, someone else would be able to market the same kind of product for a much more competitive price. And of course it happened.

Nicholas R. of Copperhill, Virginia, has been selling wet cleaning solutions for some time now and he has now been able to obtain a steady supply of brushes that work on a similar static charge principle as the Sensor Brush. The key factor here is that Nicholas R. is selling his Sensor Sweep brushes for US $15 plus $7 shipping for a total price of US $22. That’s a whole lot better than the Sensor Brush, but does it work as well?

Nicholas R. was kind enough to send me a review sample of the Sensor Sweep, so here we go (I must apologize to Nicholas for the length of time it took me to get this review going, as I was in the midst of a photographic slump and had not been very active of late).

About Sensor Sweep
The Sensor Sweep has black brush filaments with a translucent plastic handle, and It comes packaged in a sealed plastic bag. The brush itself has an additional protective plastic tube placed over it and along with the package is a nicely sized plastic tube for storage. Within the instruction sheet are two strips of velium paper that you use to charge the brush filaments before cleaning the camera.

This is the primary difference between the two dry-cleaning brushes, the Sensor Brush uses air to charge, while the Sensor Sweep uses friction to build up the charge, somewhat similar in concept to shuffling your feet on carpet as a kid and then touching your best friend to shock him. If you lose the velium paper, Nicholas suggests glossy magazine paper as a good alternative.

Using the Sensor Sweep
Before you can use the Sensor Sweep for cleaning the camera, you need to clean the brush itself. The instruction sheet states that you must use distilled water for the cleaning.

Distilled water? Where the heck does one get distilled water? A trip to my local Safeway supermarket got me a 4 liter jug of distilled water for CAN $2, but my wife advised me that other stores sell the same amount for just over $1.

Cleaning the brush requires a mild soap like baby shampoo, but only a tiny amount, like drop or two. As bad luck would have it, we ran out of baby shampoo in our house, so I moistened the brush in a bowl of the distilled water and then brushed both sides with some Dove bar soap. I stirred the bowl of water with the brush being careful not to get the entire brush wet. If you do dip the whole brush in and get the metal part that holds the brush filaments to the plastic handle then you have to wait 24-hours for drying before being able to use the brush. With only the brush tips wet, your wait is only an hour.

I used some Kodak lens tissue to dry the brush and left it alone for nearly two-hours to allow for plenty of time to dry. Once dry, I used a blower bulb to blow the brush and then proceeded to swipe the brush on the velium paper.

I swiped fairly quickly back and forth across the plastic several dozen times and then following Nicholas R’s instructions, I swiped the brush like it was a windshield wiper for both sides of the brush another dozen times each. These two motions will give the brush the charge it needs to attract dust.

Before cleaning the camera, I took a reference shot of white foam-core board with the 70-200 lens filling the frame to see how dirty my D100’s sensor was. The 70-200 was mounted on a tripod and remained in place for the two reference shots for consistency.

Then I plugged in my AC adapter into the D100 to safely lockup the mirror of the D100 to access the sensor for cleaning and then gave the CCD a couple of swipes. I took a second shot of the white foam board to see how the Sensor Sweep did in cleaning the Sensor.

The results were somewhat inconclusive because it seemed that my camera was not very dirty to begin with, so there wasn’t much to work with.

Next I did the unthinkable and purposely made my sensor dirty by shaking a dust cloth and then using my mirror locked-up D100 as a dust catcher. I charged up the Sensor Sweep and swiped again and this time the results were clearly conclusive.

I decided not to use the foam-core board again, as it has too much micro grunge of its own to be a good test subject and instead, used the clear blue sky of some summer weather that has finally appeared in Vancouver.


D100 sensor pre-cleaning
Shot of clear bue sky after Auto Levels adjustment


D100 after first cleaning - I was lazy and did not charge the brush for the second lower sweep, hence the new pieces of dust you see in the lower, far left side. If you're not careful with any cleaning method, you risk introducing new dust spots on the sensor as seen here.


D100 after second proper cleaning - still didn't get that piece of dust on the left side, but the sensor looks pretty good now. Third sweep should get it all.

The Sensor Sweep is about half the width of APS-C digital sensors, so you need to do at least two sweeps to clean the sensor. Just make sure you weren't lazy like me and properly blow the brush clean and then charge it up again before sweeping.

Conclusion
Admittedly, the Sensor Sweep is not quite as quick and easy as the Sensor Brush because of the need for manual sweeping on the velium paper to charge it instead of canned or blown air, but the cost savings is so great that it does not seem worth quibbling about for the sake of a few minutes of your time.

For the same money, you can buy several Sensor Sweeps and have one in each of your main camera bags, as well as one kept at home base. And if you lose one, well, you won’t need to sing the old Kansas song, Dust in the Wind, because it won’t be a hundred bucks blown into thin air.

The Sensor Sweep is a no-brainer recommendation of a real world product at a real world cost.

Link to Copperhill Cleaning


January 19, 2006

For most dust, the hand bulb is an effective way to remove it from the sensor.

The way the professional camera service people clean both the sensor and lenses is the same. Alcohol and lens cleaning tissue. You can get 70% alcohol at almost any supermarket or pharmacy. Lens cleaning tissue should be available at any camera store. Wrap a lens cleaning tissue around a q-tip, chop stick, straw or other stick-like thing. Get just enough alcohol on it to get the tissue wet. Don't dunk it in the alcohol. Start at the center of the lens/sensor and go in circles until you reach the outer edge. That's it.

The dust on your sensor will be most visible at small aperture settings like f22. Imagine the light coming through the aperture, hitting the filter where the dust lands, then hitting the sensor behind it. If the light comes from a large area like f2, the shadow of the dust will be fuzzed out. Small dust will cast almost no shadow at all. If the light comes from a small area like f22, the shadow will be very sharp. Even small dust will cast a clear shadow.

You mention metal filings coming from mounting and unmounting lenses. Don't forget the sliding pieces of the mechanical shutter. BTW, there's also an electronic shutter but the mechanical one protects the sensor from getting burned out from being exposed to light ALL the time.

Khouri Giordano


 
 
 
host excellence
what's new | photography | edwin's world | readers gallery | site map | NikonLinks | wedding photography

Correspondence & About this website

Copyright © 1998-2008 Edwin Leong

Google
 

WWW  CameraHobby.com